Reflections from the pastoral ministry of an Evangelical Catholic Priest.
02 April, 2012
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Favorite Links
- American Papist Blog
- American Spectator
- Archbishop Tim Dolan's (NY) Blog
- Big Blue Wave
- Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC News Site)
- Catholic Dialogue Blog
- Catholic Education Resource Center
- Catholic Exchange
- Catholic Heritage Website (Ireland)
- Catholic Insight
- Catholic News Agency
- Catholic Online
- Catholic Sensibility
- Catholic, and Loving It
- CTV News Site
- Ethics and Public Policy Center
- First Things
- Fr. Raymond De Souza - National Post Columnist
- Fr. Raymond deSouza personal blog
- Freethroughthought blog (excellent site)
- Friar Rick's Webblog
- Get Religion.org
- Global TV News Site
- Holy Post - National Post Religious Blog
- Inside Catholic Blog
- LifeSiteNews
- New Advent
- Pave the Way Foundation
- Priests for Life Canada Website
- ProLife Blog
- Roman Catholic Diocese of Pembroke
- Rosary for the Bishops
- Salt & Light TV - Canadian Catholic Television Website
- Sandro Magister
- Sane Conservatism
- SoCon (social conservative)
- Sylvia's Website: Canadian Clergy Sex Abuse Cases
- The Catholic Register
- The Hermeneutic of Continuity
- The National Post: Canada's National Daily
- The New Jesuit Review
- The New York Times Website
- Vox Nova
- What Does Prayer Really Say - Priest bolg
- Whispers in the Loggia

Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(1527)
-
▼
April
(115)
- Deconstructing the “Bible Endorses Slavery” Meme |...
- The Screwtape Letters by C.S. Lewis Comes to the S...
- I Agree with Mark Shea's taking on of Michael Vori...
- Has the 'real Ratzinger' come out to play? | Natio...
- Video: Jimmy Kimmel rips on Obama, Secret Service ...
- Egypt: No trial for those responsible for Coptic m...
- Could he be the first canadian pope? - Vatican Ins...
- Africa, a Sunday of bloodshed for Christians - Vat...
- Anti-Bullying Tzar Bullies Christians During Anti-...
- Petition in Support of Motion 312 - Sign up if you...
- UK: Could the Church be forced to celebrate gay we...
- The media’s portrayal of the persecuted Church - V...
- LCWR-Vatican tensions: Fr. James Martin sides with...
- Should Catholic Schools Be Able to Fire Teachers O...
- CATHOLIC PREROGATIVES - The Catholic League | The ...
- Let’s give intellectually disabled the right to eu...
- Timothy Dolan - 2012 TIME 100: The Most Influentia...
- ‘Angry Queers’ smash church windows in Portland | ...
- None dare call it apostasy | LifeSiteNews.com
- Little Boy Shocks a Guitar Store Owner with his In...
- The Vatican and the Sisters
- “Lapsed” Catholics… | The American Catholic
- Atheists in the Comboxes
- PQ claims halal meat 'slams against Quebec values'...
- Rosa DeLauro, CNS, and the Disoriented Catholic Le...
- Can You Be Good Without God?
- George Weigel: The Betrayal of Religious Freedom b...
- We find Jesus in the most unexpected places....
- Just how small is an atom?
- Rosa DeLauro, CNS, and the Disoriented Catholic Le...
- Charles Colson's Ecumenism of the Trenches' | Dail...
- Is the church corrupt? - Catholic America - The Wa...
- Science Will Never Explain Why There’s Something R...
- ‘He Always Has His Arms Outstreched to Me’ - the i...
- Bishops resisting diocesan shake-up |
- Court orders SNAP to release internal records : Ne...
- Why Do We Suffer? The Theological Answer of St Pau...
- Watching the Civil War | The American Catholic - a...
- Multiculturalism is not tolerance: Jackson Doughar...
- Without a doubt, the refrain to this song could be...
- A Habit (or lack-thereof) of Disobedience
- Benedict Doesn’t Make Headlines | First Things
- What Conservative Catholics Should Keep Doing
- On the Sin of Rash Judgment as Humorously Depicted...
- Te Deum laudamus!: VIDEO: Christendom's Donna Beth...
- Pope Benedict XVI: Conservative Catholics hoping ‘...
- BIG BLUE WAVE: Canada's 2010 abortion stats are ou...
- Taking, Making and Faking Life | Daily News | NCRe...
- Why the Church Is Right About Life and Love | Dail...
- Two excellent bits of advice to we orthodox Cathol...
- Liberal radio host: "I'm sick of Catholic scum and...
- CTVNews.ca Photo Gallery -- Hubble: A Window to th...
- Pope: Prayer Strengthens the Church | Daily News |...
- U.S. clinic offers sex selection service to Indo-C...
- China and the Great Catholic What-If | Crisis Maga...
- Society of Pius X Responds Positively to Overture ...
- Pope reflects on his birthday, his baptism, and hi...
- "Catholic" versus "Protestant" Ethics, Bryan Capla...
- 'Nay, Nay' works for comedians but it's not funny ...
- Birth numbers suggest female-fetus abortions more ...
- Church suspends Mass in Philippine mall over trees...
- A transitional papacy? - Vatican Insider
- My Take: Catholic bishops against the common good ...
- My Take: Catholic bishops against the common good ...
- Young Catholic women try to modernize the message ...
- Christians Debate: Was Jesus For Small Government?...
- Scratch an Atheist, Find a Fundamentalist |Blogs |...
- Happy 85th Birthday, Pope Benedict! | Daily News |...
- Date set as Ex-priest takes case to top court
- The untold story of the Titanic’s Catholic priest ...
- Ever wonder why men become priests? Here's a great...
- POWERFUL Catholic Election Ad Rocks Internet (Vide...
- Ontario government minister rebukes bishops on Cat...
- BIG BLUE WAVE: 'Responsibility' as the ultimate pr...
- Stunning (miraculous?) victory for Kings over Canu...
- Scientists '99 percent' certain they have found li...
- Benedict XVI reveals he would prefer an Italian Po...
- Top 10 Catholic News Sites | St. Peter's List
- Massachusetts Considers Legalizing Assisted Suicid...
- Toronto man may have 1,000 siblings through sperm ...
- NASA rocked by global warming rebellion
- Silenced priest told to reflect on situation
- Was JFK Right to Uphold an ‘Absolute’ Separation o...
- Catholic Abuse Scandals Continues To Take Toll On ...
- National Post readers on why they believe — or don...
- U.S. Religious Knowledge Quiz
- Fr. Robert Barron's Word On Fire - Music: Springst...
- Dawkins and Pell battle it out in one hell of a de...
- Cardinal Dolan Talks of Role of Religion in Politi...
- God's Laughter Day |Blogs | NCRegister.com
- In 2012, No Religious Center Is Holding - NYTimes....
- God's Laughter Day |Blogs | NCRegister.com
- Jesus is Real to Me – A Mediation on the Gospel fo...
- Holy Saturday: The Thanksgiving
- Pope Benedict’s telling of ‘axe’ falling on him in...
- Is religion part of human nature? | Holy Post | Na...
- Pope Assails ‘Disobedience’ Among Priests - NYTime...
- Irish newspaper prints anti-Christian diatribe : N...
- The hermeneutic of continuity: A moving approach t...
- A Catholic Accuses Atheists of ‘Magical Thinking’…...
-
▼
April
(115)

"One of the things grownups understand is that things like the epistle to the Colossians were not written by a wizard who could wave a wand and eradicate an institution that had existed absolutely everywhere the fallen human lived since the dawn of time."
ReplyDeleteSo the author of the Epistle to the Colossians was an moral relativist with regards to slavery. I don't think the pope is going to like that.
Rationalist1
Rationalist: What do you think is happening at the Holy Post? I know that Charlie is off on sick leave as he's had a setback with his back surgery, but it's been so long without a new article that all the comment threads have been closed after being open for 72 hrs. Strange.
DeleteFr. Tim
Not sure Fr. Tim. Thought it might have been because of Holy Week.
DeleteI was seriously disappointed with Mr. Shea for that line however. Saying that the author of the Epistle to the Collossians realized there was nothing he could do about slavery so he just repeated the culturally accepted zeitgeist about it is appalling. It leaves one open to saying that about all sorts of verses in Scripture that one finds troubling. Mr. Shea was desperate. to get out of that one.
Hope you're not tiring yourself out during Holy Week. Take some time off afterwards if you can.
Rationalist1
you spoke too soon. There's a new post at NO.
DeleteRationalist: Actually, the logic and argument he's making is founded in the same methodology that scripture scholars have used for hundreds of years: 'Sitz en liben'. He is placing the teaching into its historical context (zeitgeist, if you will) so as to better understand its meaning. It's the antithesis of relativism. It is an attempt to best discern what is an orthodox interpretation of what is written... to distill the essence of the teaching so that we can apply it wisely in our 21st Century times. It is an example of Mark using one of the Vatican II lodestars - 'ressourcement', a return to the original sources (or as far back as we can go - things get murky in the pre-Nicean epoch of the nascent Christian Churches) to ensure fidelity and harmony to the earliest wisdom of our Catholic Tradition.
DeleteToday is my last break before dashing into the big Holy Week celebrations. God willing, I will be able to get to my cottage for two or three days of R & R next week. I pray you'll have a peaceful and joyous celebration with your family during what promises to be a wonderful long weekend - weather wise.
Fr. Tim
But One could also, using Mr. Shea's line of reasoning, argue that any Scriptural Teaching that mirrored that society's prevailing ethics could be called into question. The obvious Scriptural denunciations of homosexuality come to mind but also one of reasons often given to not allow women priests, that Jesus never picked any women apostles. One could argue that Jesus was only accommodating the cultural norms of the day and not wanting to rock too many boats
DeleteRationalist1
Good point Rationalist1.
ReplyDeleteI would take your argument one step farther and point out that if "Sola Scriptura" is an insufficient basis for moral reasoning, then why not dispense with scripture altogether? Since one must look to historical context, tradition, and modern moral understandings in order to properly interpret scriptures, scripture becomes largely superfluous to the underpinnings of our moral reasoning. Scripture on the question slavery is simply an impediment to be rationalized away so that a proper moral understanding can be arrived at.
As I have pointed out before, Christinaity is like a big comfy woolen sweater. It may keep one comfortable on a cold day, and it might even look fetching when you wear it...but just pull at one stitch and the whole thing soon unravels.
Cheers...Martin
Rationalist: Your error is in equating Jesus and Paul. Jesus broke any number of social and religious conventions (eating with sinners, touching lepers, including women in his followers, letting prostitutes touch him, etc) because he was the Messiah, the 2nd person of the Trinity. Paul was simply a post resurrection follower and evangelist. He would not have the same capacity as Jesus to see beyond the zeitgeist of his time.
ReplyDeleteFr. Tim
Then staying only within Paul (or possibly Paul in the case of Collosians) then is one free to discount any teaching of Paul that is in conformity with the culture of the time as Mr. Shea did with the slavery example. To me that's a rather poor exegetical process.
DeleteRationalist1
Rationalist: Even Paul would tell us not just to listen to him! One needs to read the Epistles in context with the Gospels ( which themselves are rooted in the Hebrew Bible). That process, and the faithful transmission of the Christian message is the responsibility of Tradition in Catholic orthodoxy. Martin is correct in his use of a wool sweater analogy... at least to a point. I would suggest that many a knot skillfully knit into a well made sweater can suffer the wear and tear of the years, even the occasional embarrassing hole in a public place without losing its form and function. That for me is what makes faith, like a warm and comfortable sweater, a true and cherished gift.
ReplyDeleteFr. Tim
But slavery is an issue where in the context of the gospels the author of the Epistle is being consistent. A more honest reply would be to say that Scriptures were silent on this issue but that Christians as co-creators with Christ the Church's understanding of slavery has evolved to fully embrace the Gospel message, etc.
DeleteMind you all God would have had to do was to lose one of the first 4 commandments centered around him and say "Thou shall not enslave another person." (I would pick the Lord's name in vain one, rather self centered if you ask me). I'm not saying people would have followed it and would not have been nuanced out of meaningfulness, but it would have provided some intellectual and moral cover for the later actions of thousands of years of human enslavement.
Anony- You are a blathering nincompoop in this reply. You claim GOD was wrong, AND SELF"CENTERED. How dare you? You are self-centered , not GOD !
DeleteAbandoned sheep - I don't declare God was wrong, except in an rather ironic way, as I don't believe that God exists. Considering that these 10 commandments are the only words that the supposed creator of the entire universe committed to print, the first four of which deal with how his created creatures, who must greater to him what amoebas are to us, are to worship and not use his name in vain. Could the vibration of air particles in a certain pattern on an obscure planet in a non descript galaxy really offed this God so much that he couldn't leave out that command and instead say Thou shall not enslave, or Thou shall not mistreat children, or Thou shall not be racist? Indeed this command has all the hallmarks of a human creation of a priestly class that was trying to inspire awe in their fellow human beings.
DeleteI'm not self-centered. I don't think the universe was created with me as the epitome of creation or that a God who created all this cares about every hair on my head (albeit not as much of a concern as it used to be). And if it was up to me I'd rather people maligned my name daily rather than enslave each other. Wouldn't you?
Rationalist1