An essential point in how to remember when dealing with the 'enemies' of the Church
In a current article on the Holy Post I responded to a comment in which someone wrote about the appropriateness of 'hating' the RC Church. I thought I'd share my response here as it is a subject I'd enjoy discussing further.
-------------------------
Prime: I believe that you have hit upon an essential issue, if
inadvertently. In your post, you use the language of 'hate' as in it is
OK to hate the RC Church. Catholics do not use that lexicography. Christ
taught us not to hate but to love our enemies.
You see, we do
not disagree with those who see the Church as the 'enemy' for she
herself views the forces ranged against her in similar fashion. It may
not be politic today to use the language of being 'soldiers for Christ' -
but surely training an army to fight for Christ means that there is an
enemy to confront.
But the Church calls us to respond by loving
our enemies (in the filial sense of the word) so as to perhaps revivify
the initial spark of grace that exists within all. We are called to be
agents of expiation for those in need by reflecting to them the Christ
who lives within us.
You see, that's what is appealing about the
Church for Catholics. It isn't that we aren't distressed 'in extremus'
by the sins of her members, clergy and hierarchy. Anyone with any sense
of justice within them could not help but be revolted and dismayed by
their sin. It's just that that is not the totality of what we see and
admire when we look at the barque of Peter. We see and hear a beauty and
wisdom that illuminates the mind and inspires the heart.
I guess that's the difference between speaking the languages of love and hate.
Thank
you for making this clear to me this morning. You've given me a
wonderful meditation to ponder this beautiful sunny Ottawa Valley day.
Fr. Tim
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(1437)
-
▼
August
(88)
- Myth Buster: Constantine Founded the Catholic Chur...
- Abuse victim ‘hurt’ by confession stance
- Catholic League on ban against clergy during NYC 9...
- 5 Things You Need to Know About The Catholic Churc...
- In Defense of Sirico, Weigel, and Novak | Regnum N...
- Young Guns | VirtuousPla.net
- Quebec doctor probes possible autism, in-vitro fer...
- A request for prayers for a departed priest
- A priest’s nightmare | Fr. Z's Blog – What Does Th...
- Natural disasters a warning to D.C. - Alexander Bu...
- American Theocracy Revisited - NYTimes.com
- Handwriting through the ages: An abridged history ...
- Youtube video produced at the outfitter's camp whe...
- The source of virtue is divine: David Warren's lat...
- Meet ten amazing young Catholics | CatholicHerald....
- Conrad Black: The consolation of holy wisdom | Ful...
- 'Ancient Aliens' Suggests Catholic Rituals Might H...
- Gone for a few days. Back on the 26th!!
- 10 things the Belief Blog learned in its first yea...
- The real story of World Youth Day
- Pope urges pilgrims in Spain to spread faith - Wor...
- Americans Have Lost Faith In Religious Leaders And...
- HOW PSYCHOTHERAPISTS HELPED SEND AN INNOCENT PRIES...
- Planned Parenthood to end abortions at 7 Arizona s...
- Pope to proclaim St John of Avila Doctor of the Un...
- WAY TOO CUTE!!! Kitten vs Dog
- An essential point in how to remember when dealing...
- The most important thing I will ever write on this...
- What Happens When a Bishop Actually Stands Up for ...
- An interesting explanation how auxiliary (and othe...
- The seal of confession and the virtue of religion
- Why does God allow suffering?
- Is shacking up bad for the kids? - The Globe and M...
- Boulder left by mayor in front of ex-wife's home r...
- Ron Paul casts himself as the American messiah in ...
- I now pronounce you, Bert, and you, Ernie – nope, ...
- Feast of the Assumption | Catholic Exchange
- Groundbreaking series on Catholicism to air on PBS...
- Bishops Criticize Tough Alabama Immigration Law - ...
- Appreciating Darwin Has Evolved | Daily News | NCR...
- The seal of confession: some basics
- DNA components made in asteroids, study suggests -...
- Antimatter belt surrounds Earth - Technology & Sci...
- NASA probe to asteroid begins collecting data - CT...
- Jesus and the “Ogre” | First Things
- Dumb Luck or Design? A Meditation on the Existence...
- Does a parish priest have time to blog?
- New Philadelphia archbishop says church singled ou...
- Muslims Attack Christian Village in Egypt -- 1 Mur...
- Defiant Fr Roy Bourgeois Dismissed from Maryknolls...
- Violence, Riots and Anarchy Continue in London, Ar...
- TSX, Dow losses deepen - Business - CBC News
- Why companies won't hire - CNN.com
- In a Jerusalem tunnel, a glimpse of an ancient war...
- Catholic Irish priest still finds great joy and fu...
- Is this the Vatican's twilight?
- Marriage and the Law of Supply and Demand - NYTime...
- We can only watch: A reflection from David Warren ...
- Poll shows 56 per cent of Canadians think immigran...
- Do we have a 'right' to die?
- Thoughts on the arrest of Linda Gibbons on Aug. 4,...
- What is ‘Roman Catholic Political Philosophy’? » F...
- Pondering and Parsing Pithy Sayings | Archdiocese ...
- Pornography’s Social Cost
- Yes, there is such a thing as an unborn baby
- Sorry, Mr Weigel: the Irish Church has problems, b...
- If The Protestant Canon Were True… | St. Joseph's ...
- Is Catholicism in the United States healthy or in ...
- No Homophobia - George Weigel - National Review On...
- Livingston man should not be hassled for wooden cr...
- What Every Catholic Needs to Know about witnessing...
- Are Biblical Laws About Homosexuality Eternal?
- Rate your priest on new Website - The West Austral...
- Ion-powered Dawn begins study of asteroid Vesta | ...
- Book Review: The Church and the New Media | St. Jo...
- Calling things by their proper names
- Professional Scientist and Amateur Philosopher Ste...
- RNS Blog: "Tuesday’s Religion News Roundup"
- We Called For the Priest and He Never Came – A Ref...
- Losing track | Sylvia's Site
- More on the Irish Scandal from the Emerald Isle he...
- Ireland and the Church
- FLASH! Fr. Z agrees with the Huffington Post. Immi...
- Preserving Our Faith: +Dolan (NY) answers the crie...
- "Non Prævalebunt." How and Why Benedict XVI Is Sta...
- I absolutely love this joke! After all, if we can'...
- Winehouse, Breivik and Deadly Ideals - NYTimes.com...
Hi Tim,
ReplyDeleteI am not a big fan of framing our public discourse in the language of war. It tends to create the kind of polarization that we frequenlty see in the US (e.g. Culture War, Culture of Death etc...), and which we increasingly see here in Canada. Not sure who started to frame the public discourse in this manner, but the Religious Right has certainly embraced this approach with gusto as they articulate an agressive, muscular, and triumphal version of Christianity in the public square.
Remember, the first casualty of real war is the truth. Propaganda is the weapon of choice, while reason and civility are muscled out of the room.
Seems to me that you want to have it both ways. When you sit in the camp of the Religious Right (as you frequently do when you align yourself with the likes of Chuck Colson or Archbishop Chaput) you seem to have no problem with metaphors of war. When the tables are turned and your critics at Holy Post frame issues with words such as "hate", you coo like a dove about loving your enemy.
Which is it - civility and reason OR metaphors of war and aggressive propaganda?
In any case, that is the view from out here in the peanut gallery.
Cheers...Martin
Speaking on Holy Post, it looks like I won't be back. I'm tired of waiting for someone to fix the damned thing so I can sign it.
ReplyDeleteHave a good summer, now that it's here! :)
Lady Janus. I thought it was just me. I'm having no success signing into NP website either.
ReplyDeleteMichael (aka Rationalist1)
No, not just you, Michael. I don't usually subscribe to conspiracy theories, but I'm starting to suspect that only a privileged few have been cleared for commenting. I have been in touch with three different people, now, about getting signed in, and there has been absolutely ZERO results.
ReplyDeleteSo screw it. Not gonna chase anyone's tail about it. There are plenty of sites with less hassle.