Reflections from the pastoral ministry of an Evangelical Catholic Priest.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Favorite Links
- American Papist Blog
- American Spectator
- Archbishop Tim Dolan's (NY) Blog
- Big Blue Wave
- Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC News Site)
- Catholic Dialogue Blog
- Catholic Education Resource Center
- Catholic Exchange
- Catholic Heritage Website (Ireland)
- Catholic Insight
- Catholic News Agency
- Catholic Online
- Catholic Sensibility
- Catholic, and Loving It
- CTV News Site
- Ethics and Public Policy Center
- First Things
- Fr. Raymond De Souza - National Post Columnist
- Fr. Raymond deSouza personal blog
- Freethroughthought blog (excellent site)
- Friar Rick's Webblog
- Get Religion.org
- Global TV News Site
- Holy Post - National Post Religious Blog
- Inside Catholic Blog
- LifeSiteNews
- New Advent
- Pave the Way Foundation
- Priests for Life Canada Website
- ProLife Blog
- Roman Catholic Diocese of Pembroke
- Rosary for the Bishops
- Salt & Light TV - Canadian Catholic Television Website
- Sandro Magister
- Sane Conservatism
- SoCon (social conservative)
- Sylvia's Website: Canadian Clergy Sex Abuse Cases
- The Catholic Register
- The Hermeneutic of Continuity
- The National Post: Canada's National Daily
- The New Jesuit Review
- The New York Times Website
- Vox Nova
- What Does Prayer Really Say - Priest bolg
- Whispers in the Loggia

Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(1527)
-
▼
February
(153)
- Great Britain bans miracles - Vatican Insider
- All Catholics now? - The Arlington Catholic Herald...
- Why do we have leap years? - World - CBC News
- George Jonas: Canadian Supreme Court puts the fina...
- Ethicists justify infanticide in major medical jou...
- The Catholic Diaspora and the Tragedy of Liberal C...
- Gigantic Prehistoric Penguins? These 'Happy Feet' ...
- BOOM...BOOM... BOOM! Damned War Drums again! Israe...
- Fellowship of Catholic Scholars - HHSMandate
- Sometimes people can speak the truth even when the...
- Secularist attacks on the Catholic faith get worse...
- Film director James Cameron leads submarine race t...
- Think Like a Catholic: 7 Questions on the Four Law...
- Excellent short reflection on the subject of the N...
- Pope to make a pronouncement on Medjugorje by 2012...
- I know that Chris Matthews is a Democrat... but do...
- From Largest to Smallest in the Universe and Back;...
- More exposure to religion means higher knowledge o...
- Euthanasia supporters, critics in Canada look to D...
- The Church is Losing Young Families | Blogs | NCRe...
- Cardinal Dolan on the Record | Daily News | NCRegi...
- Father Barron and Edmund Burke on Atheism | The Am...
- Catholics, Evangelicals find common ground over bi...
- The B.C. Catholic Paper - Catholic Church in Canad...
- BIG BLUE WAVE: Bioethicists: Infanticide for socia...
- If Jesus Was on Facebook Would You Add Him As Your...
- Alberta doctors continue to bill province for trea...
- BIG BLUE WAVE: Brave New World of Reproductive Jus...
- Making Lent skin deep with tattoos: Yes, but will ...
- Catholics, episode one, BBC Four, review - Telegra...
- Researchers Find Flaw in Faster-Than-Light Experim...
- Remembering Bishop Faber MacDonald, a divine fiddl...
- 3 Reasons the Catholic Church Can Rule On Sexualit...
- To wear the ashes
- NASA discovers black hole with 20 million mile-per...
- Clerical Narcissism and Lent | First Things
- Ice Age plant revived after 30,000 years in frozen...
- A Day in the Life of Pope Benedict | Daily News | ...
- Father Spitzer's Tips for Pro-Lifers | Daily News ...
- You Can Look It Up: A Dictionary of Philosophers a...
- Has 'Anonymous' been heard of before? Say about 20...
- Aggie Catholics: LENT 2012
- Benedict XVI stifles rumours regarding his resigna...
- Here's Christopher Hitchen's last column from Atla...
- Hitchens, Chesterton, and “The Fall into Mysticism...
- Seeing an Image of the Priesthood in “Wego” the Bu...
- Life Comes Through The Cross; ‘Life’ Lessons
- The True Story of the First Crusade - NYTimes.com
- Canadians sparkle in galaxy of science stars - The...
- Demography, Contraception and Fiscal Melt Down | T...
- Dolan calls for evangelisation with a smile - Vati...
- Good News Obscured by Intrigues
- A success with ADULT stem cells! Proof positive th...
- CBC News - Scout leaders quietly removed, document...
- Quebec church wades into controversy over Edith Pi...
- PolitiFact | Keeping facts straight on 98% of Cath...
- Cardinal-Designate Dolan's Tips for Evangelization...
- Archbishop Chaput’s weekly column: It’s not a ‘com...
- Mandatory religion course doesn’t infringe on free...
- Pope warns of 'oppressive' power of finance, media...
- Cardinal-to-be dons Maple Leafs sweater at the Vat...
- TheRecord - Thomas Collins is one of us
- Birth Control, Bishops and Religious Authority - N...
- Vatican commission on Medjugorje will report this ...
- They call him '22-minute Dolan'
- Obama poised to accept nuclear armed Iran - Intern...
- New Fake Rights Trump Old Real Ones
- So, a bishop walks into a bar...
- Does the Church Know How to Reach the Modern World...
- Pope Reassures the Faithful: 'We Never Fall From t...
- Some more of Sylvia MacEachern's writings from the...
- Vatican calls rector of Peru's Pontifical Universi...
- A new Kindle user posts a list of books that shoul...
- Vatican's spiraling scandal reveals Machiavellian ...
- Bird-flu: Should researchers publish the data on t...
- St. Valentine
- Standing on My Head: The Father of Lies
- Nicki Minaj makes her Grammy moment all about the ...
- The Terrorists Who Couldn’t Bomb Straight | Swampl...
- News-Church Treasures Saved / News Releases / Home...
- John Allen: withdrawal of abuse suit against Vatic...
- Is your wireless network safe? | CTV News
- Weigel: Obama policy furthers sexual license, rest...
- In the end, no matter how bruised and battered Hol...
- Higgs Boson: CERN turns up power on Large Hadron C...
- Sylvia MacEachern of Sylvia's Site has a long hist...
- Birth Control Debate: Why Catholic Bishops Have Lo...
- Views on provocative Real Catholic TV station ange...
- Religious, Not Spiritual | Daily News | NCRegister...
- Married drivers get fewer tickets than common-laws...
- The essential Whitney Houston tracks - The Globe a...
- We Canadians suffer through snow and winter... but...
- Paedophilia, those who won’t toe Ratzinger’s line ...
- Congregation for the Clergy: Learning from the Lep...
- Whitney Houston dead at age 48: Singer's body foun...
- Catholic Bishops: Don’t Revise, Rescind - By Georg...
- Rex Murphy on Obama’s war against Christianity: Wh...
- Barack Obama confuses theologies in forcing birth ...
- Plot to kill the Pope more reminiscent of the Borg...
- With Vatican's Backing, Catholics Address Sex Abus...
-
▼
February
(153)

Hi Tim,
ReplyDeleteIt strikes me that Mr. Jonas is implying that parents have an absolute right to indoctrinate their children in any belief, up to and including, the withholding of factual information from the child.
How would we feel if a parent was indoctrinating their child in Nazism? Would that parental "right" to control a child incldude withdrawal of the child from any class in a school that might contradict Nazism?
What if the object of the indoctrination involved racism, genocidal beliefs, criminal culture, sado masachism etc...? Does society ever have the right to override or interfer with a parent's alleged right to indoctrinate a child? What about a child's right to accurate information about the world? Does the parent own the child's mind, body and soul until the age of emancipation? Is a child the sole and exclusive "property" of a parent?
I would venture that most reasonable people would concede that at some point a parent's right to indoctrinate a child is limited. It is not an absolute right. I would argue that a child has a right to factual and accurate age approriate information about the world. I would even say that society has an obligation to provide it. It is one of the reasons that public education is one of the cornerstones of open modern democracies.
No one is saying a parent is prevented from instructing a child in religion at home or in the community outside of school. In my view, the SCC has made a reasonable decision. Children should recieve factual information about multiple religious beliefs in school...just as they should receive factual information about evolution, astronomy, geology, sociology, history, literature etc... at school.
Not sure I understand the durm und strang from Mr. Jonas. If religion is truly a free choice, then it can only be a meaningful choice when all the facts are known.
Cheers...Martin
We do not own children as parents, we care for them, feed them, nuture them, protect them and love them. It is not our job to mold them into anyone's image, especially not our image. We need to respect their individuality, and give them the foundation that will allow them to make the best decisions about their life in the future. And after we are gone, if they remember us with love, we will have entered the only heaven that really matters.
ReplyDeleteRationalist1